Comparison of Lower Extremity Lean Mass Between Multi-frequency Bioelectrical Impedance Analysis and Dual-Energy X-ray Absorptiometry in Athletic College-Aged Men and Women

Purpose:To compare lower extremity lean mass (LELM) and lean body mass (LBM) between bioelectrical impedance analysis (BIA) devices and dual-energy x-ray absorptiometry (DXA). Methods:Thirty-one women and 26 men underwent body composition testing. Inter-instrument reliability and bias were assessed with intraclass correlation coefficients and t tests, respectively. Results:Systematic underestimation bias for LELM was observed in men (approximately 3 kg) and women (approximately 1.5 kg) (both P < .01). Wide limits of agreement (LOA) were evident in men (approximately 4.2 kg) and women (approximately 4.9 kg). Overestimation error in men increased with the amount of LELM. Overestimation (P < .01) and proportional (P = .02) biases were noted for LBM in women. Wide LOAs were noted for women (approximately 8 to 9.7 kg) and men (6.7 to 12 kg). Conclusions:BIA did not agree well with DXA for assessing LELM, but was more accurate for LBM. BIA consistently underestimated LELM and error depended on the amount of LELM. BIA should be used and interpreted conservatively.